5 Mistakes Beginner Authors Make When Writing Women's Fiction
5 Tips on How to Avoid Them
When I transitioned from writing romance to women’s fiction, I was excited! I no longer had to write a happily ever after ending. I didn’t have to focus only on a romantic relationship, but I could write deeper stories about one woman’s journey and all her issues, just like all the emotionally rich books I loved to read. But I hadn’t fully grasped what women’s fiction was.
Here’s the thing: writing compelling women's fiction isn't just about the plot or women’s “issues.” Yes, it’s about her journey, but most importantly, it's about creating a central character who feels deeply and authentically human. A trap many new women’s fiction writers fall into is that they think if they just create a sympathetic situation (middle-aged woman whose husband has left her, empty next mom finds a new life or career), readers will automatically root for our heroine. But readers don’t connect with a situation; they connect with a person navigating that situation. Leaning too hard on plot events without building a complex character at the center is a classic mistake that creates shallow stories.
The wonderful thing is that we can fix this problem. Here are the five biggest mistakes I see authors make when writing women’s fiction, and how you can move beyond the surface-level cardboard characters to writing messy, complicated, and utterly fascinating characters who truly feel alive, ensuring your heroine leaps off the page, grabs your reader, and refuses to be forgotten.
Common Mistakes
Mistake #1: The Passive Protagonist
We love heroines who make things happen, take control of their lives, and drive their story. The biggest mistake that can stall a story before it even begins is writing a passive protagonist. This is a character the story happens to, rather than one who makes the story happen. She gets swept up by events, pushed into action by someone else, or simply reacts to things as they come. Yes, her husband of twenty years has left her to pursue his goal of being a rockstar and is sleeping with a woman young enough to be his daughter, but now what? She can’t continue to be a victim of her situation; she has to take her own action based on her needs and goals. What the heck, let’s let her decide to go with him on the road and be his manager to try to make him love her again, but realize along this journey that she really doesn’t want him back. Nope, she wants her own career away from him. Wishing him well, she leaves her pathetic husband in the incapable hands of his new girlfriend. Goodbye Amigo! We can cheer for this woman, right?
A quick way to diagnose if you have a passive heroine is with the "Sexy Lamp Test." Could you replace your female character with a sexy lamp, and the plot would still basically work? Does she just exist to be a prize for the hero, a person to be rescued, or a sounding board for his problems? If the answer is yes, you have a prop, not a protagonist. A story is about a character chasing a goal, and if your main character doesn't have a goal of her own, the narrative has no engine. She becomes a passenger in her own life, and that's a journey no reader wants to follow.
Think of Katniss Everdeen in The Hunger Games. The story doesn't just happen to her. She shows agency from the very start. She doesn’t let her sister get chosen; she makes the active, story-defining choice to volunteer. In the arena, she doesn’t just hide and wait. She chooses to ally with Rue. She chooses to shoot an arrow at the Gamemakers. Her decisions are the engine of the whole story.
Actionable Tip: To fix the mistake of the passive heroine, look at every major turning point in your plot. Highlight it. Ask yourself: Is my heroine making a choice here, or is a choice being made for her? Is she actively chasing a goal, or just reacting to the latest disaster? If she’s not in the driver’s seat, it’s time to hand her the keys. What matters is that the choice is hers.
Mistake #2: The Invincible "Strong Female Character"
Somewhere along the way, the call for “strong female characters” got twisted into a call for “invincible female characters.” This created a new stereotype: the super-competent, emotionally bulletproof warrior who never shows fear, never messes up, and never needs help. But that isn't strength; it's just another kind of flat character. A character who can't be hurt can't be brave. A character who never doubts can't be inspiring.
This mistake kills reader connection. We don't relate to perfection; we relate to the struggle. Seeing a character's fears, insecurities, and moments of despair is what makes her human. Real strength isn't the absence of weakness; it's acting in spite of it. It allows us to root for her, not because we expect her to win, but because we understand what she has to lose.
A perfect example is Ellen Ripley from Alien. In the first film, she's not a hardened warrior; she's an officer trying to follow the rules. She's smart and capable, but she is also terrified. We see her panic, we see her desperation, and that’s what makes her final victory so satisfying. Her strength is amplified by her vulnerability. It’s emotional, not just physical. We see the same character in Sarah Connor from the first Terminator.
Actionable Tip: To fix your superhuman character, embrace vulnerability. Figure out your heroine’s deepest fear. Not a surface-level fear like spiders, but a profound, emotional fear—like the fear of failure, abandonment, or not being good enough. Then, don’t just tell us she has this fear. Show us. Put her in a situation where she has to face it, and let her be genuinely scared. Her true strength will be revealed when she decides to take that next step anyway.
Mistake #3: The Fake Flaw
Perfect characters are boring. And irritating. But an even bigger mistake than a perfect character is one with a fake flaw. A fake flaw is just a positive trait in disguise, like "she's a perfectionist" (I tell my students the same thing about describing weaknesses in an interview) or "she just cares too much." These don't create real conflict or feel authentic.
An authentic flaw is a genuine failing with negative consequences. Maybe she’s arrogant and constantly underestimates her enemies. Maybe her insecurity makes her sabotage her own relationships. These are flaws that can cause a character to truly fail. Flaws are essential for creating tension and a real character arc. A character's biggest flaw should be a genuine obstacle standing between her and her goal. It's the internal fight she has to win while she's fighting the external one. Scrooge in A Christmas Carol had to overcome the belief that money brings happiness before he could stop being greedy and embrace warm relationships and find true happiness.
The queen of flawed heroines is Elizabeth Bennet from Pride and Prejudice. Her main flaw is right in the title: prejudice. Her pride leads her to make a snap judgment about Mr. Darcy, and her prejudice makes her see everything he does in a negative light. This isn't a cute quirk; it's the central obstacle of the novel. It causes her pain and nearly costs her a chance at happiness. Her entire character arc is the journey of recognizing and overcoming this flaw.
Actionable Tip: The fix for this problem is to give your heroine a flaw that directly contradicts her main goal. If she needs to build an alliance to save her business, make her deeply mistrusting of others. If she needs to uncover a subtle family secret, make her impulsive and quick to jump to conclusions. The battle between her goal and her flaw will generate tension and give her a clear path for personal growth.
Mistake #4: The One-Dimensional "Badass"
This mistake is common: reducing a complex woman to a single adjective. “Tough” is an adjective, not a personality. A great heroine isn't defined by one generic trait like being a "badass." Real people are a messy, contradictory mix of traits, and your characters should be too. Falling into this trap is often a response to the "damsel in distress," but it creates an equally flat stereotype.
What else is your heroine besides strong? Is she secretly a romantic who cries at sad movies? Is she a brilliant strategist who can’t cook to save her life? Is she fiercely loyal to her friends but ruthless in the boardroom? These specific, sometimes conflicting, details are what make a person memorable.
Think about Amy Dunne from Gone Girl. She is undeniably one of the toughest characters in modern fiction. But she isn't just tough. She’s brilliant, meticulous, and creative. She's also narcissistic, vengeful, and terrifyingly manipulative. She can put on the perfect "cool girl" face while internally seething with rage. The character is fascinating because she's a complex bundle of conflicting traits that feel scarily real. You don't have to like her to be captivated by her.
Actionable Tip: To avoid writing a one-dimensional character, sit down and list ten things that describe your heroine’s personality. The only rule is you can't use the words “strong,” “tough,” “fierce,” or “badass.” What are her hobbies? Her pet peeves? Her secret shames? Her weird habits? Flesh her out as a person, not just a protagonist. Give her layers that might even contradict each other.
Mistake #5: Forgetting Her Humanity
This final mistake brings everything else together: focusing so much on a character's role in the story that you forget to make her a person. Before your character is a hero, a mother, or a love interest, she has to be a human being. A common symptom of this mistake is the “inventory list” introduction. “She was five-foot-seven, with long blonde hair, blue eyes, and a slender build.” That isn’t a person; it’s a police blotter. It tells us what she looks like, but nothing about who she is.
A character’s inner life is where she truly comes alive for the reader. What are her small, everyday opinions? What does she think about when she's alone, doing something boring like washing dishes or waiting for a bus? Does she have a unique way of seeing the world that colors your narration? How does she want to control the world to stay safe?
Think of Eleanor Oliphant from Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine. Most of that book isn't about big plot events. It's about Eleanor’s intensely specific, often strange, inner world. We learn about her rigid weekly schedule, her silent judgments of her coworkers, and her lonely weekends. We are completely immersed in her unvarnished humanity. Her heroic journey is about learning how to connect with someone. Because we know her so intimately as a person, her struggle and her triumph are incredibly moving.
Actionable Tip: The solution is to write a "day in the life" scene for your heroine that has nothing to do with your main plot. Write about her waking up, making breakfast, commuting to work. What is she thinking about? What are her little rituals? This exercise might never end up in your book, but it will force you to see her as a whole person, not just a function of the plot.
Women’s Fiction is Different From Other Fiction
If you are noticing that women’s fiction is much more character-driven, that the plot is secondary, and that readers read for connection, you are starting to understand the women’s fiction novel.
So, if you feel like your women's fiction story isn't landing with readers, the fix is almost always to look inward at your heroine. It’s not about a more dramatic plot; it’s about a more deeply understood character.
To recap the five mistakes to avoid:
First, don't write a passive protagonist; give her agency to drive the story.
Second, avoid the invincible character; embrace vulnerability to create true strength.
Third, skip the fake flaws; define authentic flaws to create meaningful internal conflict.
Fourth, go beyond the one-dimensional "badass"; build a multi-layered, specific personality.
And finally, don't forget her humanity; write a human being first, and a character second.
Building a character this way is a challenge because you are creating a human being who is complex and feels real to you and your readers. But if you do the work, you won’t just have a character. You’ll have a person who lives in your reader’s mind long after they’ve turned the final page.
Which of these five mistakes have you found most challenging in your own writing? Or which one do you see most often in books you read? Share your thoughts in the comments below! I read every single one, and it’s a great way for us all to learn from each other.
Interested in writing a novel? Join my 12 Month Novel Writing Program. This structured class will provide lessons, exercises, writing support, monthly live sessions, group discussions, accountability, editing and publishing tips.