Collaborating with Characters
When Your Protagonist Has Opinions and Talks Back
I’m currently in the process of writing a romance novel. The two characters meet in an airport when they fail to get on a connecting flight, and they are stranded until the next morning. The plot idea is to get them to begin talking, getting to know each other, build a friendship, and when they reach their destination, realize that a romantic relationship is forbidden because of a work relationship they don’t yet know they will have.
He is playful, funny, a risk taker. She is more reserved and careful, and doesn’t make decisions quickly or impulsively. The idea was for the relationship to build slowly, but the characters had other ideas. I told Abby, my female protagonist, to take it slowly, but she slammed the door on my outline and said, “I don’t think so, not this time. He’s cute and I’m going for it.”
It happened in an early scene when they were getting off a terminal train, and Abby hurt her foot. I was writing from his point of view, and this is what happened:
She limped and walked slowly. I felt bad for her, so I stopped and handed her my soccer ball to free up my hands. “Come on. I’ll carry you.”
“No, you won’t.”
“Climb on my back.”
“I will not,” She said in a cute, indignant tone that made me want to smile. But I didn’t.
I picked her up and placed her standing on a chair. Then I backed up into her. “Climb on. It will be fun. And I need the exercise.”
She hesitated.
I looked over my shoulder. “Come on. Live a little. I won’t drop you.”
Though she looked at me like I was crazy, she hooked one arm around my shoulder and chest, and with the other, she held on to my soccer ball. I grabbed her rolling carry-on by the handle and started walking.
“I feel like an idiot.” Her voice shook—part nervous, part amused.
I ran a little, swaying from left to right. Abby shrieked and held on tighter. Having her legs wrapped around my waist was a bit of a turn-on. Okay, it was more than a bit exciting, but I tried to focus on where I was going, not the inappropriate thoughts of turning her around so that our hips were pressed together. I ran the last few steps, and by the time we arrived, we were both laughing.
“Oh my God, I can’t believe I agreed to do that.”
“Tell me you didn’t have fun,” I said, enjoying the flushed looks on her cheeks. It was the first time she didn’t look stressed or worried.
She gazed up at me. “I did actually. I felt like I was ten years old again.” She looked around. “Other passengers probably think we’re crazy.”
When she says, “I can’t believe I agreed to do that.” That was really me speaking. I hadn’t planned on her being that impulsive early on. I expected her to keep her distance a little longer. But she jumped into this, and it made things more interesting, which will change the following scenes and take the relationship in a new direction.
The illusion of control
Okay, so here’s the truth about plotting and outlining. It’s a great roadmap, but it only gives us the illusion of control over our novel. You can chart every twist and turn, color-code the emotional beats, and even storyboard the climax—but the moment you start writing, your characters might start resisting. Suddenly, that carefully planned moment when your heroine forgives her ex? She’s not having it. She’s still angry. And the sidekick you created just to lighten the mood? He’s stealing every scene and demanding his own subplot.
This is where the tension lives—between the part of you that wants to stick to the plan and the part that’s discovering the real story in real time. Outlining can make you feel productive and organized, and it’s necessary in my opinion. But discovery writing—that instinctual, sometimes chaotic, “what if she doesn’t leave him?” writing—is where surprises live. It’s where emotional truth can override structure, where characters behave in ways you didn’t expect, but somehow feel inevitable. Let’s be honest, it’s what makes writing so thrilling!
The danger, of course, is that veering off course can lead to a messy middle or an unfinished draft. But the reward? Characters with depth, arcs with emotional weight, and plot turns that feel organic instead of engineered.
So, what do you do when your character goes rogue? You listen. You ask questions. You step away from your outline—not to toss it, but to renegotiate the terms of your story. Because good storytelling isn't about control. It's about collaboration.
Characters as collaborators (without losing the story)
Here’s where it gets tricky. Trusting your characters doesn’t mean handing them the keyboard and walking away. It means treating them like collaborators—creative equals who challenge your assumptions, push for emotional honesty, and sometimes flat-out refuse to say the lines you wrote for them.
But if you've ever let a character "speak" during a scene, you’ve probably noticed something: it can feel like you’re wandering. Like you’re writing pages of dialogue or introspection with no clear direction. That’s because character-led writing is powerful—but raw. And raw work needs shaping.
So, how do you balance this collaboration with the need for a strong, compelling narrative?
1. Know their core desire
Even when you're letting a character lead a scene, you're not just writing random behavior. You're tracking their core desire—the thing they want, consciously or unconsciously. If every choice they make is connected to that desire (to be loved, to feel safe, to prove their worth), then even surprising actions will feel purposeful. When you write from desire, you're not freewriting. You're discovering.
When Abby climbs onto his back, she’s acting on her core desire to be more decisive and to make decisions that benefit her. This will serve her well when she has to make career decisions later in the novel. It’s a first step, and my character knew she had to take it. It worked because I (the author) clearly understand her core desires and goals.
2. Use the outline as a compass, not a cage
Let your outline show you where the story needs to go. But if a character pushes back—if she refuses to take the job, make the call, or forgive the betrayal—ask yourself why. Does this resistance reveal something deeper about her wound? Her worldview? Her arc? Adjust the path accordingly, not by abandoning structure, but by rethinking motivation and stakes.
3. Pause for a debrief
When a character “goes off script,” don’t just follow blindly. Pause. Journal in their voice. Ask:
Why did you do that?
What are you afraid of right now?
What outcome are you hoping for in this scene?
This quick inner dialogue can keep your story grounded, even when it swerves.
4. Scene goals keep you on track
Think like a director: every scene should move the story forward—emotionally or plot-wise. If your character wants to wander, make sure that wandering reveals something new. Are we closer to a revelation? A decision? A shift in the relationship? If not, cut or condense later—but don’t shut it down too early. Sometimes detours are where the gold is. Follow your character for a while. Pay attention to what they’re doing. Listening to your characters’ voices can uncover their motivations and lead you exactly where your story needs to be.
Writing Prompt: rewrite the scene their way
Choose a key scene in your novel—one you’ve already written—and rewrite it from your character’s point of view, but with them in charge.
Let them refuse the action you planned for them. Let them say what they really think. Let them do what feels natural to them, even if it derails your plot.
Now compare the two versions.
What changed?
What surprised you?
Did the new version open up emotional depth, or reveal a fear or flaw that hadn’t been on the page before?
This is how you learn to collaborate—not by asking polite questions, but by testing your trust. Sometimes your outline knows the direction. But your character knows the why.
Interested in writing a novel? Join my 12 Month Novel Writing Program. This structured class will provide lessons, exercises, writing support, monthly live sessions, group discussions, accountability, editing and publishing tips.